Choosing among storybook-style vinyl records is less about one universal "best" pick and more about matching the title, format, condition, and price to the collection you are building. In this group, the choices range from a sealed 1984 Gremlins set to used Disney, Star Wars, and The Hobbit read-along or storyteller releases. The main decision is whether you want the lowest listed price, a specific franchise, a 7-inch read-along format, or a larger 12-inch LP connected to Rankin/Bass and Disneyland.
Quick take
- For the lowest listed price: The STAR WARS Movie Story Book (1979) - 7\" Vinyl Record 45RPM - VG is the least expensive choice in the set and focuses on a 7-inch 45 RPM movie story format.
- For a sealed 1980s bundle: The Gremlins Vinyl Records and Story Books 1 & 3 33 & 1/3 RPM, 1984 Edition Sealed stands out because it is marked new, sealed, and includes a set of five story books and records.
- For classic Disney read-along appeal: The Vintage Disney Snow White Seven Dwarfs Book and Record Read-Along 7 Inch 33 RPM combines a 24-page illustrated book with a 7-inch 33⅓ RPM record.
- For a larger storyteller LP: The The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG is the 12-inch option and centers on songs and dialogue from the original motion picture release.
Listed price comparison
The listed prices run from USD 13.98 to USD 49.99, so the lowest-priced record is 72% below the highest-priced one. That spread matters most if you are choosing between a small-format 7-inch record and the larger Hobbit LP.
| Product | Listed price | Price bar |
|---|---|---|
| STAR WARS Movie Story Book (1979) - 7\" Vinyl Record 45RPM - VG | USD 13.98 | |
| Gremlins Vinyl Records and Story Books 1 & 3 33 & 1/3 RPM, 1984 Edition Sealed | USD 14.99 | |
| Vintage Disney Snow White Seven Dwarfs Book and Record Read-Along 7 Inch 33 RPM | USD 15.25 | |
| The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG | USD 49.99 |
Decision matrix
Pick Gremlins if your priority is an 80s movie tie-in with a sealed, new-condition presentation. The custom bundle status and set of five story books and records make it the most multi-piece choice here.
Pick Snow White if you want a Disney read-along format with songs, narration, chime prompts, and a 24-page illustrated book. It is a strong fit for someone specifically looking for a children's music and soundtrack category release.
Pick Star Wars if you want the lowest listed price and a 1979 movie story book format. The title's 7-inch 45 RPM format also separates it from the 33 RPM read-along selections.
Pick The Hobbit if your collection is focused on Rankin/Bass, J.R.R. Tolkien, Disneyland storyteller releases, or 12-inch LP formats. It is the highest-priced item here, so it makes the most sense when that exact title and format are the draw.
Concise product notes
Gremlins Vinyl Records and Story Books 1 & 3 33 & 1/3 RPM, 1984 Edition Sealed
The Gremlins set is the clearest choice for a shopper who wants a sealed 1984 release with a bundle angle rather than a single loose record. Its attributes call out a new condition, paper sleeve, multicolor presentation, 33 & 1/3 RPM playback, and a set of five story books and records, which gives it a different shape from the single-title read-along options. The limitation is focus: this is very specifically tied to Gremlins, the 80s era, and story-book materials, so it is less flexible for someone looking for classic Disney, Star Wars, or a 12-inch LP format.
Vintage Disney Snow White Seven Dwarfs Book and Record Read-Along 7 Inch 33 RPM
The Snow White read-along is the natural fit for someone drawn to vintage Disney story-and-song formats. It includes a 24-page fully illustrated book and a 7-inch 33⅓ RPM vinyl record, with word-for-word narration, chime prompts, songs, musical backgrounds, and sound effects. The Disneyland record label and Walt Disney artist attribution also make the theme very direct. Its tradeoff is condition and page character: it is used, and the description mentions a black-and-white sketch on page 24 that was colored in by a child artist, which may matter to shoppers who prefer cleaner book interiors.
STAR WARS Movie Story Book (1979) - 7\" Vinyl Record 45RPM - VG
The Star Wars choice works best for someone who wants a 1979 movie story book record at the lowest listed price in this comparison. It is also the only 45 RPM entry here, which helps distinguish it from the 33 RPM read-along selections. The title and attributes point to a 7-inch black vinyl record in a paper sleeve, with Luke Skywalker listed as artist. The limitation is that it is a used copy with VG in the title, and the focus is more compact than the Gremlins bundle or the Hobbit 12-inch storyteller LP.
The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG
The Hobbit LP is the most title-specific pick for shoppers interested in Rankin/Bass, J.R.R. Tolkien, and Disneyland storyteller records. Its 12-inch record size sets it apart from the 7-inch Disney and Star Wars options, and the release title centers on songs and dialogue from the original motion picture. The internal 12-page booklet gives it a book-and-record identity rather than being only a disc. The clear limitation is cost and condition: it carries the highest listed price, is used, and the outer jacket is described with light vintage shelf wear and edge rubbing along the spine.
Final recommendation
For most shoppers comparing these four vinyl records, the best starting point is the exact franchise you want to add to your shelf. The price range is wide enough that format and title should drive the decision before small price differences do.
If you simply want the lowest listed price, choose the STAR WARS Movie Story Book (1979) - 7\" Vinyl Record 45RPM - VG at USD 13.98. It gives you the Star Wars storybook angle, a 1979 date in the title, and the distinct 45 RPM format.
If you want the most pieces in one package, the Gremlins Vinyl Records and Story Books 1 & 3 33 & 1/3 RPM, 1984 Edition Sealed is the standout because it is marked as a new custom bundle and described as a set of five story books and records.
If your priority is a traditional Disney read-along, the Vintage Disney Snow White Seven Dwarfs Book and Record Read-Along 7 Inch 33 RPM is the most direct match, especially with the 24-page illustrated book, chime prompts, songs, narration, and Disneyland label.
Choose The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG only if its 1977 Rankin/Bass Disneyland storyteller identity and 12-inch LP format are worth the higher listed price to you. It sits at the top of the range, but it is also the only Hobbit and 12-inch storyteller LP option in this comparison.