Buying vintage sheet music is usually a choice between playability, collectibility, display appeal, and how many individual pieces you want at once. A single piano score can be the cleaner choice for a focused pianist or Brahms collector, while a multi-piece lot can make more sense for framing, browsing, or building an ephemera collection around film, pop, or early-1900s cover art.
Quick take
- Best focused classical piano pick: Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA. It centers on Brahms's "Lullaby (Wiegenlied)" in a piano solo arrangement by Elizabeth Gest.
- Best classical practice-and-recreation collection: Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA. It is a Volume Two piano collection arranged and edited by Maxwell Eckstein, with sixty-nine famous melodies noted on the cover.
- Best early cover-art lot: Vintage Early 1900s Sheet Music Lot Of 6- 1900s-30s Film & Art Deco Covers. It brings together six pieces with film tie-ins, European compositions, and Art Deco-style covers.
- Best pop and soundtrack lot: Vintage Sheet Music Lot 6 Pieces Moon River Blue Velvet Because Theyre Young. It includes "Moon River," "Blue Velvet," "Because They're Young," and other mid-century pieces tied to pop standards and movie themes.
Listed price comparison
The price range runs from $15.88 to $19.99, with the lowest listed item about 21% below the highest. The spread is narrow, so the better decision is less about chasing the absolute lowest number and more about whether you want one focused score, a piano collection, or a six-piece lot.
| Product | Listed price | Price bar |
|---|---|---|
| Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA | USD 15.88 | |
| Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA | USD 19.88 | |
| Vintage Early 1900s Sheet Music Lot Of 6- 1900s-30s Film & Art Deco Covers | USD 19.97 | |
| Vintage Sheet Music Lot 6 Pieces Moon River Blue Velvet Because Theyre Young | USD 19.99 |
Decision matrix
| Shopper priority | Strongest match | Why it fits |
|---|---|---|
| A single classical piano piece | Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA | It is a piano score for Brahms's "Lullaby (Wiegenlied)," arranged for piano solo by Elizabeth Gest. |
| A broader piano book | Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA | It is a collection/song book for piano, with Volume Two described as containing sixty-nine famous melodies. |
| Early-1900s graphics and mixed titles | Vintage Early 1900s Sheet Music Lot Of 6- 1900s-30s Film & Art Deco Covers | The lot includes six original pieces with film tie-in songs, European compositions, and Art Deco-style covers. |
| Pop, soundtrack, and vocal material | Vintage Sheet Music Lot 6 Pieces Moon River Blue Velvet Because Theyre Young | Its genre attributes include Pop, Soundtracks, and Vocal, and the title names "Moon River," "Blue Velvet," and "Because They're Young." |
| Guitar plus piano flexibility | Vintage Sheet Music Lot 6 Pieces Moon River Blue Velvet Because Theyre Young | Its instrument attributes include acoustic guitar, electric guitar, and piano. |
| Classical-only shopping | Vintage Boston Music Lullaby or Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music | Both are marked Classical and Piano, but one is a single Brahms score while the other is a collection/song book. |
Concise product notes
Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA
This is the clearest choice for someone who wants a focused classical piano item rather than a mixed bundle. The piece is Brahms's "Lullaby (Wiegenlied)," arranged for piano solo by Elizabeth Gest, with Boston Music Co. imprint text and a 1927 copyright line. The cover description, hearth illustration, and catalogue-style back cover also give it period character beyond the music itself. Its limitation is scope: it is centered on one piano score, not a collection, and the condition is listed as Good. If your goal is multiple titles or varied genres, one of the six-piece lots offers more breadth.
Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA
This piano collection is the better fit if you want more pages of playable material in one vintage book. The title identifies it as Volume Two of "Let Us Have Music for Piano," arranged and edited by Maxwell Eckstein, and the cover references sixty-nine famous melodies with lyrics included with most numbers. It stays in the Classical genre and Piano instrument lane, which makes it more focused than the pop and film lots. The tradeoff is that it is a collection/song book from 1942 rather than an individual display-focused cover title; shoppers seeking Art Deco graphics or named movie themes may prefer the lots.
Vintage Early 1900s Sheet Music Lot Of 6- 1900s-30s Film & Art Deco Covers
This lot stands out for shoppers who care about visual variety and older sheet-music ephemera. It includes six pieces from the early 1900s through the 1930s, with titles such as "Amina - Egyptian Serenade," "Goodnight My Love," "I, Yi, Yi, Yi, Yi," "Just a Gigolo," "Tina," and "The Man on the Flying Trapeze." The mix of film tie-ins, European compositions, and Art Deco-style covers makes it appealing for display or collecting. The limitation is condition-related: the description mentions typical age-related wear, small tears, light creasing, spine and corner wear, and a separated cover on "Amina."
Vintage Sheet Music Lot 6 Pieces Moon River Blue Velvet Because Theyre Young
Choose this lot if recognizable mid-century song titles matter most. It is anchored by "Moon River" from "Breakfast at Tiffany's," with Johnny Mercer and Henry Mancini named, and also includes "Blue Velvet," "Because They're Young," and "More." The genre attributes cover Pop, Soundtracks, and Vocal, while the instrument attributes include acoustic guitar, electric guitar, and piano, giving it a wider performance angle than the piano-only classical options. Its limitation is visible in the condition description: vintage paper age, edge wear, light creasing, period writing, and some foxing or staining are part of the package.
How to choose between them
If you are buying for a pianist who wants a single recognizable classical work, the 1927 Brahms "Lullaby" score is the most direct pick. It has the lowest listed price in the group and stays tightly aligned with Piano, Classical, and piano score attributes.
If you want a piano book with many melodies rather than one composition, the Carl Fischer Volume Two collection is more practical. The title and cover language point to a larger set of famous melodies, and the format is listed as Collection/Song Book and Sheet Music.
If the purpose is collecting or framing, the early-1900s six-piece lot has the strongest cover-art angle. The title calls out 1900s-30s Film & Art Deco Covers, and the included pieces span several named songs and styles. It is less tailored to one instrument because the common attributes list Format and Genre but do not name an instrument.
If you want familiar pop and movie material, the "Moon River," "Blue Velvet," and "Because They're Young" lot is the most targeted. It also has the broadest instrument attribute set, covering acoustic guitar, electric guitar, and piano.
Final recommendation
For the most focused and lowest-cost choice, pick Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA at USD 15.88. It is the right match when a single 1927 Brahms piano score is more appealing than a mixed bundle.
For the best all-around playing collection, choose Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA at USD 19.88, especially if the collection/song book format and sixty-nine famous melodies are the draw.
For collectors who want quantity and visual variety, the decision comes down to era and genre: choose the Early 1900s Sheet Music Lot Of 6 for film and Art Deco-style covers, or the Moon River Blue Velvet Because Theyre Young lot for Pop, Soundtracks, Vocal, and guitar-plus-piano attributes.