Choosing among vintage vinyl records is rarely just about the music. For shoppers, the real decision is whether the record is meant to anchor a soundtrack collection, bring back a specific movie memory, add a book-and-record format to a shelf, or simply offer the lowest listed entry point. Here, the choice spans classic Hollywood soundtrack material, Disney-related story records, and two Gremlins read-along formats.
Quick take
- Best for classic film soundtrack collectors: BEN HUR Soundtrack MGM DELUXE EDITION IEI Boxed Set Book Vinyl LP 1959 Near Mint, because it centers on a 1959 film score and a deluxe boxed-set presentation.
- Best for Disney soundtrack nostalgia: Disneyland Records: Robin Hood by Roger Miller: 12" LP Vinyl Record 1973 w/Book, because it pairs the Robin Hood soundtrack with Roger Miller and an illustrated book.
- Best compact Gremlins read-along choice: 1984 Gremlins: The Gift Of The Mogwai Read Along Book Record 33RPM Vintage, because it uses a book-record story format tied to the 1984 film.
- Best sealed children's record-and-book pick: SEALED CHILDREN'S PICTURE BOOK & 33 RPM - BUENA VISTA 466 - "GREMLINS, because it is marked new with a sealed feature.
Listed price comparison
The listed range runs from USD 10.00 to USD 32.99, with the lowest price about 70% below the highest. That makes the decision less about a simple low-to-high ladder and more about which format, artist, and movie connection matters most.
| Vinyl record | Listed price | Price bar |
|---|---|---|
| BEN HUR Soundtrack MGM DELUXE EDITION IEI Boxed Set Book Vinyl LP 1959 Near Mint | USD 10.00 | |
| 1984 Gremlins: The Gift Of The Mogwai Read Along Book Record 33RPM Vintage | USD 11.30 | |
| SEALED CHILDREN'S PICTURE BOOK & 33 RPM - BUENA VISTA 466 - "GREMLINS | USD 15.00 | |
| Disneyland Records: Robin Hood by Roger Miller: 12" LP Vinyl Record 1973 w/Book | USD 32.99 |
Decision matrix
Choose by collection theme: If your shelf leans toward classic cinema, the Ben Hur deluxe boxed set is the most direct fit. If the collection is centered on Disney soundtracks, the Robin Hood record is the clearest match. If the goal is children's story records or movie tie-in read-alongs, the two Gremlins choices are more focused.
Choose by format: The Ben Hur and Robin Hood selections are 12-inch LP-oriented options, while both Gremlins records are 7-inch formats. That distinction matters if you collect by record size, display format, or book-and-record presentation.
Choose by condition emphasis: The Ben Hur record is used but carries Near Mint record grading. The Robin Hood and 1984 Gremlins records are used, while the Buena Vista Gremlins item is marked new and sealed. For shoppers who prioritize unopened presentation, the Buena Vista Gremlins record stands apart.
Choose by artist focus: Roger Miller is the named artist on the Robin Hood release. The Ben Hur and 1984 Gremlins records list various artists, while the Buena Vista Gremlins record lists Disney. If a specific named performer matters, Robin Hood is the more targeted option.
Concise product notes
BEN HUR Soundtrack MGM DELUXE EDITION IEI Boxed Set Book Vinyl LP 1959 Near Mint
This is the strongest choice for someone building around classic Hollywood soundtrack vinyl. The title points to the 1959 Ben Hur soundtrack, and the attributes add a deluxe edition, boxed set context, black vinyl, 33 RPM speed, and Near Mint record grading. It also has a book element, which gives it more shelf presence than a plain soundtrack LP. The main limitation is that it is still a used record, so shoppers focused only on new or sealed items may prefer the Buena Vista Gremlins option instead. It is also more about film score collecting than children's storybook listening.
Disneyland Records: Robin Hood by Roger Miller: 12" LP Vinyl Record 1973 w/Book
This pick is the most specific Disney soundtrack option in the group: Robin Hood, Roger Miller, Disneyland Records, and a 1973 release all appear directly in the title or product details. The included illustrated book gives it extra appeal for shoppers who like record-and-book combinations rather than audio-only vinyl. It also lists a cardboard sleeve and Very Good Plus inlay condition. The tradeoff is that it sits at the top of the price spread, so it makes the most sense when the Robin Hood connection or Roger Miller credit is the main reason to buy.
1984 Gremlins: The Gift Of The Mogwai Read Along Book Record 33RPM Vintage
This is the leaner Gremlins read-along choice, centered on The Gift Of The Mogwai and a vintage 1984 movie tie-in. It is a good fit for shoppers who want the story-record experience rather than a full soundtrack LP, especially since the format is built around following along with a book while listening. The various-artists credit keeps the emphasis on the story and movie connection instead of a single performer. The limitation is condition: it is used, and unlike the Buena Vista Gremlins record, it is not described as sealed or new.
SEALED CHILDREN'S PICTURE BOOK & 33 RPM - BUENA VISTA 466 - "GREMLINS
This Gremlins option is the one to focus on if sealed presentation is a priority. It is marked new, lists Disney as the artist, and the description identifies a record with a 24-page book. For collectors of children's vinyl records, the Buena Vista 466 title detail also makes it feel more catalog-specific than a generic movie tie-in. The limitation is that the title is less tidy and less story-specific than The Gift Of The Mogwai, so shoppers who want that exact Gremlins read-along title may find the 1984 version more straightforward.
Final recommendation
For most soundtrack collectors, BEN HUR Soundtrack MGM DELUXE EDITION IEI Boxed Set Book Vinyl LP 1959 Near Mint is the best first look: it has the lowest listed price at USD 10.00, a deluxe boxed-set identity, and Near Mint record grading while staying firmly in the soundtrack lane.
For Disney-focused collectors, Disneyland Records: Robin Hood by Roger Miller: 12" LP Vinyl Record 1973 w/Book is the most targeted pick despite being the highest listed option at USD 32.99. The Roger Miller credit, Robin Hood theme, and illustrated book make it the clearest match for that specific interest.
For Gremlins shoppers, choose by presentation. 1984 Gremlins: The Gift Of The Mogwai Read Along Book Record 33RPM Vintage is better if the named story title matters most. SEALED CHILDREN'S PICTURE BOOK & 33 RPM - BUENA VISTA 466 - "GREMLINS is better if a new, sealed children's picture book and record format is the deciding factor.