Choosing sheet music often comes down to what matters most: a recognizable song, a playable piano arrangement, an older antique-era piece, or a collection with multiple melodies. The four choices here span 1912 to 1952, with single-song sheets, piano scores, and a larger piano collection all represented. The best pick depends less on one universal winner and more on whether you want a specific title, a classical piano setting, or an earlier popular-music artifact.
Quick take
- Best low-price single title: *Sheet Music Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes 1952 Slim Willet Perry Como* is the lowest-priced choice and is marked Very Good, making it the most straightforward pick for shoppers focused on that 1952 song title.
- Best Brahms piano option: *Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA* is the clearest fit for someone looking for a classical piano score tied to Johannes Brahms and Elizabeth Gest.
- Best multi-piece piano collection: *Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA* stands out because it is a collection/song book rather than a single sheet.
- Best antique-era popular music choice: *Take A Little Tip From Father, Lillian E. Bradley, 1912 Antique sheet music* is the oldest dated piece and includes Gene Buck cover-art attribution.
Listed price comparison
The listed prices run from USD 5.99 to USD 19.88, and the lowest listed price is 70% below the highest. That spread is meaningful: the least expensive piece is a mid-century single song, while the highest-priced choice is a larger 1942 piano collection.
| Pick | Listed price | Relative bar |
|---|---|---|
| Sheet Music Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes 1952 Slim Willet Perry Como | USD 5.99 | |
| Take A Little Tip From Father, Lillian E. Bradley, 1912 Antique sheet music | USD 11.38 | |
| Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA | USD 15.88 | |
| Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA | USD 19.88 |
Decision matrix
| Shopper priority | Strongest fit | Why it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest listed cost | *Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes* | It is the lowest-priced item in the group and carries a Very Good condition label. |
| Classical piano focus | *Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music* | It is identified as a piano score and sheet music in the classical genre. |
| More than one piece of music | *Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2* | It is listed as a collection/song book and sheet music for piano. |
| Earliest dated item | *Take A Little Tip From Father* | It has an exact year of 1912 and falls under popular music from the 1910-1919 decade. |
| Mid-century musical-title interest | *Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes* | The title ties the piece to 1952 and names Slim Willet and Perry Como. |
| Cover-art or antique appeal | *Take A Little Tip From Father* | It includes Gene Buck as artist and references a photo of Carol Schroder on the cover. |
Concise product notes
Sheet Music Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes 1952 Slim Willet Perry Como
This is the simplest choice for a shopper who wants the named 1952 song and does not need a piano collection or classical score. Its condition is marked Very Good, and the attributes identify the format as sheet music with Meridian Music as publisher. The title also names Slim Willet and Perry Como, which gives it a specific mid-century music connection rather than a broad anthology feel. The main limitation is genre fit: it is categorized under musicals, so it will not satisfy someone looking specifically for a classical piano score or an antique 1910s popular-music piece. It is also a single title, not a song book.
Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA
This one is the clearest match for a pianist who wants a classical piece in a defined arrangement. The title and description identify Brahms's "Lullaby (Wiegenlied)," arranged for piano solo by Elizabeth Gest, with Boston Music Co. and a 1927 copyright connection. The attributes list it as Piano Score, Sheet Music, with piano as the instrument and classical as the genre. That makes the role very specific and easy to understand. The tradeoff is that it is marked Good rather than Very Good, and it is centered on one classical lullaby rather than offering the breadth of a collection/song book.
Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA
Choose this if you want a broader piano item instead of a single-song sheet. It is listed as Collection/Song Book, Sheet Music, and the description names *Let Us Have Music for Piano, Volume Two*, arranged and edited by Maxwell Eckstein, with sixty-nine famous melodies referenced on the cover. The attributes also keep the focus on classical piano, making it useful for shoppers who want a piano-centered book with multiple selections. The limitation is cost position: it is the highest-priced item in the group. It is also marked Good, so condition-sensitive shoppers may prefer the lower-priced 1952 piece marked Very Good.
Take A Little Tip From Father, Lillian E. Bradley, 1912 Antique sheet music
This is the standout for antique-era interest. It carries an Exact Year: 1912, is categorized as popular music, and includes Gene Buck as artist. The description references "Take A Little Tip From Father," Berlin & Snyder, Ted Snyder Co. of New York, and a photo of Carol Schroder on the cover, giving it a strong period-specific identity. It also lists the instrument as piano and voice, which separates it from the piano-only classical choices. The limitation is condition-related: it is marked Good, with age-consistent wear described at the extremities and a small closed edge tear along the left edge.
How to choose by use case
If you are buying to play, start with instrument and format. The Brahms title is the cleanest single-piece piano score, while the Carl Fischer volume is better suited to someone who wants a collection/song book for piano. If piano and voice matters, the 1912 *Take A Little Tip From Father* listing is the only one that states that instrument pairing.
If you are buying around era, the spread is straightforward. The 1912 antique piece is the earliest, the Brahms score sits in 1927, the Carl Fischer piano volume is from 1942, and *Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes* points to 1952. That makes the decision easy for shoppers building around a decade rather than a composer or format.
If condition wording is your priority, the 1952 *Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes* sheet is the only one here marked Very Good. The other three are marked Good, so they may still be appealing for their era, genre, or format, but they do not carry the same condition label.
Final recommendation
For most shoppers who simply want an affordable, clearly identified piece of sheet music, start with *Sheet Music Don't Let the Stars Get in Your Eyes 1952 Slim Willet Perry Como* because it is the lowest listed price and the only option marked Very Good. For a pianist focused on classical music, choose *Vintage Boston Music Lullaby Brahms Elizabeth Gest Piano Sheet Music 1927 USA* if you want a single Brahms arrangement, or *Vintage Carl Fischer Let Us Have Music For Piano Vol 2 Sheet Music 1942 USA* if the collection/song book format matters more than the price. If age and antique popular-music character are the draw, *Take A Little Tip From Father, Lillian E. Bradley, 1912 Antique sheet music* is the most distinctive choice because of its exact 1912 year, Gene Buck artist attribution, and piano-and-voice instrument listing.