Choosing vintage sheet music often comes down to focus versus variety: do you want classical piano material aimed at an intermediate player, or a broader assortment of musical-sheet selections spanning several decades? These two lots take distinctly different approaches, with a $3.35 gap between their listed prices.
Quick verdict
Pick Lot of 2 Vintage Scribner Classical Sheet Music Books Piano 1931, 1946 when the priority is classical music for piano and an intermediate experience level. Its two-book format is more concentrated, and its description points to substantial classical music to play.
Choose ANTIQUE & VINTAGE 1917-1972 Sheet Music Lot of 9 - Mixed Instruments when a larger assortment, mixed-instrument scope, and musical genre are more appealing. At USD 9.00, it is the lower-priced choice, though its description calls out age-related wear across parts of the lot.
At a glance
| Comparison point | Scribner Classical Piano Books | 1917-1972 Mixed Instruments Lot |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 12.35 | USD 9.00 |
| Format | Sheet Music | Sheet Music |
| Main musical direction | Classical; piano | Musicals; mixed instruments |
| Experience level | Intermediate | Not stated |
| Lot size named in title | 2 books | 9 pieces |
Where each lot wins
Scribner Classical Piano Books: focused practice material
The Scribner lot has the clearer musical destination. It is identified as classical sheet music for piano and carries an intermediate experience-level designation, making it the natural match for a pianist who wants repertoire in that lane rather than a mixed selection. The description also emphasizes that there is plenty of classical music within the books, so the appeal is more about usable piano content than collecting a cross-section of genres.
1917-1972 Mixed Instruments Lot: larger, varied assortment
The 1917-1972 lot wins on quantity and range. Its title identifies nine pieces over a long date span, while the genre is musicals and the instruments are mixed. That combination suits a shopper drawn to a varied vintage assortment rather than a piano-specific pair of books. Its USD 9.00 listed price also makes it the straightforward choice for keeping the initial outlay lower.
Product notes
Lot of 2 Vintage Scribner Classical Sheet Music Books Piano 1931, 1946
This lot is the more purposeful choice for an intermediate pianist seeking classical sheet music. The instrument and genre are both clearly aligned-piano and classical-and the two-book grouping keeps the selection centered on that use. The outer edges have some wear, so it is not the pick for someone whose main goal is especially crisp-looking vintage covers. At USD 12.35, it also sits at the high end of this comparison. Still, for a player who would rather receive focused classical material than sort through multiple mixed-instrument pieces, that concentration is its main advantage. It makes the most sense as a repertoire-oriented choice for piano sessions or for adding older classical books to a music shelf.
ANTIQUE & VINTAGE 1917-1972 Sheet Music Lot of 9 - Mixed Instruments
This is the stronger match for someone who enjoys the variety and visual character of an assorted vintage sheet-music lot. The nine-piece title, mixed-instrument description, and musicals genre give it a wider scope than the piano-centered Scribner books. It is also priced at USD 9.00. The trade-off is condition variation: the description mentions yellowing, cover and corner wear, and that some pieces have handwriting, folds, or tears. Those traits may suit a shopper comfortable with age-related character, but they make the lot less targeted for a uniform-looking collection. Choose it when the appeal is browsing several older musical pieces across the 1917-1972 span rather than building a focused classical piano library.
Final choice by use case
- For intermediate classical piano playing: choose the Lot of 2 Vintage Scribner Classical Sheet Music Books Piano 1931, 1946.
- For a larger musical-theater-oriented assortment: choose the ANTIQUE & VINTAGE 1917-1972 Sheet Music Lot of 9 - Mixed Instruments.
- For the lower listed price: choose the 1917-1972 lot.
- For a more focused piano format: choose the Scribner books.
