Choosing a *Hobbit* record means deciding between an expanded Rankin/Bass set and a Storyteller-oriented Disneyland LP. Both center on the 1977 era, but their program styles, physical presentation, and listed prices point to different kinds of collectors and listeners.
Quick verdict
Start with the format of the purchase: THE HOBBIT Original Soundtrack 2 Vinyl Records Set LP & Book Rankin Bass SP ED is the larger set, while The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG is the Storyteller LP. The listed prices are USD 25 apart, so it makes sense to choose by the type of *Hobbit* record you want rather than treating them as interchangeable.
At-a-glance comparison
| Detail | THE HOBBIT Original Soundtrack 2 Vinyl Records Set LP & Book Rankin Bass SP ED | The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 74.99 | USD 49.99 |
| Physical presentation | Two records and a book | Internal 12-page booklet |
| Program identity | Complete original soundtrack; soundtrack genre | Songs and dialogue; Comedy & Spoken Word genre |
| Exterior details | Used; original cover | Used; light shelf wear and spine-edge rubbing described |
Where each record wins
THE HOBBIT Original Soundtrack 2 Vinyl Records Set LP & Book Rankin Bass SP ED
This set is the stronger choice for shoppers who put special-edition identity and original-cover presentation first. Those package-specific traits make it well suited to someone who wants the record set itself to be a central part of the purchase, not simply the audio program.
The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG
The Disneyland title is the better match when songs and dialogue, along with a Comedy & Spoken Word classification, match the intended listen. Its Storyteller framing clearly distinguishes it from a complete-soundtrack set and gives it a more narrative-oriented identity.
Product notes
THE HOBBIT Original Soundtrack 2 Vinyl Records Set LP & Book Rankin Bass SP ED
For a Rankin/Bass listener building around the film music, this special-edition set offers a 1970s English-language presentation on 33 RPM records. The original-cover feature gives the package a clear collecting angle, while the cardboard sleeve is part of its physical presentation. It fits shoppers who want a more substantial *Hobbit* music release with a book included alongside the records. The trade-off is direct: at USD 74.99, it is the higher-listed choice in this comparison. That makes the package-oriented appeal most compelling for someone who specifically wants this expanded soundtrack configuration.
The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG
This record suits someone drawn to the Disneyland 3819 identification and the black-vinyl presentation. Its internal 12-page booklet adds a physical companion to the record, and the 1977 framing keeps the selection centered on the Rankin/Bass-era *Hobbit* release. The outer jacket is described with light vintage shelf wear and edge rubbing along the spine, while the graphics are described as bright and bold. That stated exterior wear is the main limitation for a shopper whose priority is a cleaner jacket. It remains a distinct choice for listeners seeking the particular Disneyland Storyteller format.
Final choice by use case
Choose THE HOBBIT Original Soundtrack 2 Vinyl Records Set LP & Book Rankin Bass SP ED when special-edition package identity and original-cover presentation are the deciding factors. Choose The Hobbit Vinyl Record 1977 Rankin Bass Disneyland 3819 Storyteller Book LP VG when the lower listed price, at USD 49.99, is the deciding factor. For a collection focused on different listening styles, the first selection favors a complete music program, while the second favors the Storyteller approach.
