If your vinyl records are going to live anywhere besides a bare shelf, outer sleeves are the first line of defense. When you're deciding between two clear LP outer-sleeve packs, you often end up weighing a thicker polyethylene sleeve against a lighter polypropylene sleeve. The CE Compass pack and the PROTECT pack both promise clear outer covers, but their listed prices, material thicknesses, and dimensions point to different buyers.
Quick Verdict
Choose the CE Compass pack if you want thicker polyethylene protection for LP jackets and single or double LPs. Choose the PROTECT pack if you prefer a lighter polypropylene sleeve with a taller fit.
At a Glance
| Product | Listed Price | Price Bar | Material & Thickness | Dimensions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CE Compass 100 Vinyl Outer Sleeves Cover - Thick 3 Mil Protective Sleeves 12.75" x 12.75 | USD 23.99 | 3 mil polyethylene | 12.75" x 12.75" | |
| PROTECT 100 Plastic Outer Sleeves Vinyl Record LP Album Plastic Covers | USD 21.95 | 2 mil polypropylene | 12.75" x 13" |
Where Each Pack Wins
- CE Compass wins for protection: The polyethylene material is described as thicker than standard covers, which makes it a logical choice for records that get handled or stored for long periods.
- PROTECT wins for lighter storage: The polypropylene material is thinner, and the taller sleeve leaves a bit more room for album jackets that run tall.
Product Notes
CE Compass 100 Vinyl Outer Sleeves Cover - Thick 3 Mil Protective Sleeves 12.75" x 12.75
This is the more substantial sleeve of the pair. The CE Compass pack is made from 3 mil polyethylene and listed at 12.75" x 12.75", a size that matches the LP jacket dimensions called out for single and double LPs. If you want a sturdier barrier between album covers and shelf wear, the thicker material gives you that layer of confidence. The model number LP_OUT_100P helps you identify the same pack if you need to reorder. The trade-off is that the sleeve is slightly shorter than the PROTECT option, which lists a 13-inch height.
PROTECT 100 Plastic Outer Sleeves Vinyl Record LP Album Plastic Covers
This is the lighter alternative. The PROTECT pack uses 2 mil polypropylene and comes in clear, with a listed size of 12.75" x 13". The extra height can be useful for oversized jackets that don't fit neatly into shorter sleeves, and the clear finish keeps the album cover artwork visible while it's protected. The pack is identified by the model name Record Sleeves and the MPN PS1213, so you can match it to the same size on a future order. The trade-off is the thinner material: at 2 mil, you don't have the extra thickness that the 3 mil CE Compass sleeve offers.
Final Choice by Use Case
- For thicker, more protective storage: Choose the CE Compass polyethylene pack.
- For lower listed price and lighter handling: Choose the PROTECT polypropylene pack.
Both packs supply the same number of clear outer sleeves for your vinyl records, so the real decision is thickness versus listed price. If the thicker material and the LP-size fit matter more, the CE Compass pack is the one to go with. If the lighter material, the taller fit, and the lower listed price sound better, the PROTECT pack is the pick.
